ChasNote

19 November 2004

Micro-Targeting’s Hidden Costs

Remember when pretty good targeting was enough? Internet ad serving technologies now enable micro-targeting by industry-vertical-and-job-function-and-relevant-niche-content, and it’s hard to find anyone who’s satisfied with plain old targeting anymore.

Better targeting? Why not.

When he’s marketing information management products that help developers do their jobs better, Mike Paradiso, CA’s VP of Worldwide Media, sees better click-through rates from banners run on developer-only sites than those same banners running on broader business or IT sites. And Kim Kochaver, Management Supervisor at MRM Gould, has had similar experiences: niche targeting generally drives higher click-through, if not always lower effective cost-per-click rates given the premiums charged for such narrow rotations.

At the same time, though, both rattled off a list of exceptions and caveats: ad creative may have more impact on response rates than targeted placements; micro-targeting for one audience attribute (say demographic or job function) ignores other attributes (like psychographic mind-set); and “sometimes a less precise placement will surprise you with terrific response.”

The long list of caveats calls into question the simple logic that the more specific the target, the better.

Kim and Mike both talked about the perils of over-targeting, or “lazy” micro-targeting. Enterprise server ads that run only adjacent to stories about servers, for example, might drive better-than-average response (not always though, see below). But it’s sloppy marketing that misses an opportunity to message to a prospect who needs servers to solve a related technology challenge. Fixing lax security, upgrading operating systems, and revamping IT management strategies will, in all likelihood, require new server hardware; yet careless micro-targeting ignores these prospects.

Looking at click-through data as a proxy for interest, we begin to calculate the real (if partial) cost of over-targeting. Vendor participants in ZDNet’s “PowerCenter” sponsorship program provide educational assets (whitepapers, case studies, webcasts, etc.) that ZDNet integrates as text links on most pages of the site. Like pages of the ZDNet site, all vendor assets are assigned to categories—hardware, software, networking, security, etc.—to facilitate category matching, one flavor of micro-targeting. When the ZDNet producers override the category-matching system, however, human insight frequently out-performs the automated ad-delivery system. The best-performing text links in April 2004 promoted server hardware on security-related pages (0.6% CTR). The next-best performers were operating-system evaluation kits posted on security-related pages (0.5% CTR) and server hardware-related pages (0.4% CTR). Operating system software assets, in fact, performed better on server hardware pages than server hardware assets on those same pages.

If ZDNet’s enterprise security content turns a million pages a week, 0.6% is 6000 prospective customers eager for buying information on that vendor’s server products—a steep opportunity cost in the name of marketing efficiency. And that doesn’t count the 99.4% of pages that didn’t drive a click.

Prospective customers don’t always structure their research according to the taxonomy of websites, nor do they self-select into database marketing buckets. As a result, job-function filtering faces the same over-targeting risk as content matching: According to IntelliQuest’s CIMS Business Study 2004, only 19% of those who's primary job responsibility is writing software programs actually report their primary job function—essentially their title—as application development or programming. I’m guessing this phenomenon affects other job functions as well.

Overly eager micro-targeting promises efficiency and often delivers it, just like turning off the lights saves on the electricity bill. But turning off the lights also comes at a cost—your staff isn't productive, isn't closing sales, and isn't manufacturing new product when the lights are out. Over-targeting can limit wasted impressions (though given the evidence, let’s be careful what impressions we call "wasted"), but it also abandons many prospective buyers who don't fit neatly into the boxes we'd like to put them in.

21 Comments:

  • learn about print on demand self publishing
    at: print on demand self publishing
    Info

    By Blogger selfpublishingtips, at 3:40 PM  

  • It's amazing what information you can find when you surf blogs, I came across yours.. great info...would you like to visit my blog as well?
    high traffic web site Please Disregard the title it's on my product web site.

    By Blogger hover-it, at 11:24 PM  

  • Your blog, It's terrific . If you ever need any printing done, I'm sure you'd be interested in Letterhead/Envelopes Try Letterhead/Envelopes

    By Blogger Shania, at 10:08 AM  

  • Your blog is great . If I can help, let me know. If you ever need any printing done, I'm sure you'd be interested in Postcards / Flyers Try Postcards / Flyers

    By Blogger Shania, at 3:07 PM  

  • Your blog, It's terrific . If you ever need any printing done, I'm sure you'd be interested in Door Hangers Try Door Hangers

    By Blogger Shania, at 5:30 PM  

  • Your blog is great . If I can help, let me know. If you ever need any printing done, I'm sure you'd be interested in Posters Posters

    By Blogger AutoI nsurance Protection, at 4:13 AM  

  • Your blog is great . If I can help, let me know. If you ever need any printing done, I'm sure you'd be interested in Letterhead/Envelopes Try Letterhead/Envelopes

    By Blogger AutoI nsurance Protection, at 11:27 AM  

  • Found your blog while surfing, great info...would you like to visit my blog as well?
    Please Disregard the title it's on my product web site.

    By Blogger Tony, at 12:15 PM  

  • It's amazing what information you can find when you surf blogs, I came across yours.. great info...would you like to visit my blog as well?
    flying ads Please Disregard the title it's on my product web site.

    By Blogger alladin, at 3:45 PM  

  • Found your blog while surfing, great info...would you like to visit my blog as well?
    flying ads Please Disregard the title it's on my product web site.

    By Blogger hover-it, at 3:23 PM  

  • It's amazing what information you can find when you surf blogs, I came across yours.. great info...would you like to visit my blog as well?
    banners Please Disregard the title it's on my product web site.

    By Blogger Tony, at 8:57 PM  

  • Found your blog while surfing, great info...would you like to visit my blog as well?
    internet marketing Please Disregard the title it's on my product web site.

    By Blogger alladin, at 1:32 PM  

  • It's amazing what information you can find when you surf blogs, I came across yours.. great info...would you like to visit my blog as well?
    popup maker Please Disregard the title it's on my product web site.

    By Blogger alladin, at 5:35 PM  

  • Hi Chas Edwards, very interesting post.

    I'm not too familiar with blogs, but I found your post " Micro-Targeting’s Hidden Costs " a good read. I was actually looking for information on automated delivery and found your post. Any recommendations for the best infromation about automated delivery?

    Nice one.

    By Blogger Joe Langer, at 8:45 AM  

  • Hello Chas Edwards,

    I am based in the UK and I stumbled across your post " Micro-Targeting’s Hidden Costs ".
    I'm quite keen on finding any useful information on digital delivery. I found some good stuuf on digital delivery but I wondered whether you may have any advice on the best resources out there.

    Thanks in advance.

    By Blogger Joe Langer, at 8:46 AM  

  • Hi Chas Edwards,

    I see you share my interest in digital delivery. Your input would mean a lot to me. If you would be so kind to visit my site and give me your feedback, I would most appreciate it.

    Thanks

    By Blogger Joe Langer, at 4:17 AM  

  • Hi Chas Edwards,

    I see you share my interest in digital delivery. Your input would mean a lot to me. If you would be so kind to visit my site and give me your feedback, I would most appreciate it.

    Thanks

    By Blogger Joe Langer, at 4:18 AM  

  • Hi Chas Edwards, very interesting post.

    I'm not too familiar with blogs, but I found your post " Micro-Targeting’s Hidden Costs " a good read. I was actually looking for information on digiserve and found your post. Any recommendations for the best infromation about digiserve?

    Nice one.

    By Blogger Matthew Humphries, at 4:50 AM  

  • Hello Chas Edwards,

    I am based in the UK and I stumbled across your post " Micro-Targeting’s Hidden Costs ".
    I'm quite keen on finding any useful information on automated download software. I found some good stuuf on automated download software but I wondered whether you may have any advice on the best resources out there.

    Thanks in advance.

    By Blogger Matthew Humphries, at 4:50 AM  

  • Please visit my blog as well and see why online marketers are now using hover ads instead of popups.web developmentweb development

    By Blogger Ad Blaster, at 2:43 AM  

  • Bots are robots that visit your site to extract data from its pages. "Good" bots include search engine crawlers like Googlebot and Yahoo! Slurp. You definitely want good bots to visit your site so your pages will show up in search engine results. marketing

    By Blogger dr.dan, at 10:08 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home